Skip to content

Covid: the problem is having handed power over to doctors

21 January 2022

Interviste e direttePostsTutti i video

Interview with Alessandro Fusillo on the Affaritaliani website by Antonio Amorosi

The lawyer Fusillo explains the mistakes made in managing the pandemic. He is pursuing lawsuits against the government for 11,000 clients. "The mainstream has killed debate"
View the original article by Antonio Amorosi at this link: https://www.affaritaliani.it/coronavirus/covid-perche-non-ne-usciamo-il-problema-aver-dato-il-potere-ai-medici-772436.html

Dissent against government policies is brought onto television to be ridiculed. Talk shows in crisis invite anti-vaxxers to boost audience share. All this while the President of the Republic, Sergio Mattarella, in an address reminiscent of a state of war, speaks of the "orderly compliance" of Italians "with what was instructed" by the institutions for the vaccination campaign, apart from "a few exceptions", when there are millions of unvaccinated people who have no intention of getting vaccinated.about:blank

“Together with our legal team, we are pursuing appeals for 5,000 healthcare workers and 6,000 over the Green Pass,” the lawyer Alessandro Fusillo tells Affaritaliani.it. The lawyer firmly declined invitations to speak on television and across mainstream media, yet he remains a point of reference for those defending themselves against the vaccine mandate or protesting against the discrimination introduced by the government.

We saw a video where you were arguing heatedly with television crews who wanted to film you for broadcast. Why have you flatly refused all invitations from the mainstream media?

I will not be made a fool of! There is an extreme dumbing down of public communication. If there were a programme where radically different opinions could be set against each other in civil debate, with everyone given the opportunity to speak their mind, I would gladly take part. But instead there is a constant brawl of grotesque spectacles where an influencer or a showgirl screams at you as if they have lost their minds. I am used to speaking in court, before courts of law, where at least there is a presiding judge who maintains order in the proceedings.

You have launched numerous lawsuits across multiple fronts. Could you give us an idea of the figures involved?

Together with our legal team, we are handling the appeals of 5,000 healthcare workers and 6,000 people over the Green Pass, and I calculate we will have just as many over the Super Green Pass. And those are just my cases. Then there are many other law firms.

Solutions?

We will not have immediate solutions because the courts take their time. But fundamental principles and statutory provisions are being violated, including international ones, so it is likely that answers will come from those quarters as well.

Yet the media depict a very different country experiencing yet another situation of extreme danger, from which one cannot opt out through individual conduct...

Intervening in a dangerous situation—say, a madman walking out into the middle of the street armed with a military rifle who must be stopped because he is dangerous—is one thing; generic risk, which includes the risk of disease, is quite another. If we elevate illnesses to unmanageable perils, then it is game over. There are millions of people who are entirely right to refuse this form of management, and they have legitimate doubts about the scientific validity of mandating these vaccines. The problem is that people do not realise the power they hold.

Could you elaborate?

If all these people refused to go to work, this whole thing would end within a matter of days, because the system obviously cannot hold up with a substantial number of people refusing to submit to a blackmailer who tells you: "unless you do this, you do not work". As lawyers, we frequently deal with blackmailers.

And what do you do in such cases?

In the criminology of extortion, the fundamental mistake one can make is to give in, because the extortionist will never stop—or rather, will not stop until the victim is destroyed.

Yet you are painting a picture of the state that is completely at odds with the prevailing narrative: a state that is saving Italians, or at least trying to...

A little logic is all it takes to see that this is the case. Someone who tells you, "unless you undergo this medical treatment"—I do not care what it is, even an elixir of long life or something that cures all ills—"I will physically prevent you from working", that is to say from surviving, from providing yourself and your family with the means of subsistence, of life... well, to me that is extortion. Whatever they may say on television, it is an ugly and very dangerous thing. To understand that, one need only listen to the flawless explanation given in the Senate some time ago by Professor Giorgio Agamben.

However, critics of this argument say that this disease is overwhelming the healthcare system, and therefore such action is legitimate...

If we hand power over to doctors, it is game over. A doctor can advise you not to smoke, not to drink, to adopt certain habits, but cannot force them upon you. Otherwise, where is the limit? Will we have to stigmatise cancer patients whose illness stems from smoking when they end up in hospital, or patients suffering from conditions that arise simply from an unhealthy lifestyle, drug use, poor diet...? And do they not place a burden on and strain our healthcare system? If we go down that road, however, we quickly arrive at the ethical State that dictates human behaviour.

In the mind of the ordinary person, politics is rotten, as is our ruling class. So the Italian thinks: let us put our trust in the medical scientists, who can give us the solution...

Rules must be made on the basis of legal criteria, not healthcare criteria. That is why we have plunged into a nightmare, and not only in Italy. We have an absurd situation where a doctor, or purported doctor, reasons by so-called scientific criteria and dictates the rules to the legislature. That means turning a medical recommendation into a legal rule. And in this collective madness unfolding before us, the medical aspect is truly irrelevant, because what actually matters is the legal aspect: namely, you cannot compel someone to undergo a medical treatment they do not wish to have. Let us remember that Popper said the defining characteristic of a scientific rule is falsifiability, so that another scientist can take it and dismantle it.

It is not an article of faith, and that carries implications...

Precisely. What we consider valid today, and on that basis force people to starve without work over something politics is demonstrating it cannot manage, could prove false in a few years' time.

Yet they would counter that hospitals are being overwhelmed... although the situation we are living through has also reminded me of the Committee of Public Safety during the French Revolution...

If we want to regulate hospital access because a portion of the population ends up in intensive care, we enter into an ethical assessment of lifestyle choices from which there is no way out. How can anyone argue that people are responsible for catching a virus—a microscopic thing—and transmitting it? The current situation is tied to specific interests. Among them: managing the landscape by controlling all citizens and selling as many pharmaceuticals as possible to line the pockets of corporations with, at best, a dubious track record.

So there is a fundamental underlying problem!?

Yes, of course, because people think rules can be drafted based on scientific criteria coming from medical science, microbiology, and virology. In my view, this is an extremely grave matter, because it marks a retreat by legal scholars in the broadest sense and is the anteroom to tyranny. In other words, there is an epistemological problem. We are managing human behaviour, which cannot be calculated in all its complexity, using medical and healthcare criteria.

We know that pharmaceutical companies are backed by investment funds that care only about making money, but you are describing and revealing a country that many cannot see.

Apart from a tiny handful of free voices in the alternative news landscape, there is total conformity. A heavy blanket has fallen over the narrative of reality. And what is more, we all know that the latest decree-law explicitly allocates communication funds whereby the government pays mass media outlets to broadcast the official line. In this deranged mechanism that we have witnessed throughout the pandemic, we have giant multinationals—the drug manufacturers—which are certainly connected to the scientific world, since drugs cannot be produced without scientific research, and which legitimately pursue profit. Now, for a pharmaceutical seller to make money for its shareholders is something I consider entirely respectable. However, if that money is made through the coercive apparatus of government, forcing drugs on citizens, well... then serious problems arise. Let us not forget that Pfizer has a history of fraud and multi-billion-dollar penalties for unfair commercial practices.

On TV they would tell you: you don't believe in science...

And what does science have to do with it? We are talking about pharmaceutical companies, not idealists sitting in laboratories studying day and night for the good of humanity. Let us be clear: I see nothing wrong with them doing their job; I find it entirely respectable. But do not come and tell me that this is science—unquestionable, indisputable, beyond reproach, almost as if it were God. There are very solid, well-defined economic interests at play.

In your view, what will happen in the coming months?

I think that in the long run the system cannot hold. Cracks are already beginning to show in hospitals that cannot cope without the suspended healthcare staff, and among the police forces who are being forced into odious duties against citizens.

This is placing law enforcement officers, in particular, in a difficult position that cannot be sustained indefinitely. It is very dangerous. And furthermore, many of them have no intention of getting vaccinated. But I ask myself: what kind of vaccine is this? The vaccinated not only fall ill, but they also transmit the disease to others.

You raised a legal issue. How should Italians view the current coercive rules?

The great jurist Francesco Carnelutti used to say that in Italy there are more than 200,000 laws, fortunately tempered by a general non-observance on the part of the people because they are inherently contradictory and open up vast ranges of interpretation. Italians merely need to return to this sensible behaviour, and this entire tragic farce will come to an end. I will continue to explain this wherever free speech is permitted, and we will see these legal actions through to the end.

Article by Antonio Amorosi

View the original article at this link: https://www.affaritaliani.it/coronavirus/covid-perche-non-ne-usciamo-il-problema-aver-dato-il-potere-ai-medici-772436.html