Handbook for healthcare workers – Law Decree 172/2021

UPDATE 1 APRIL 2022: Everything stated here remains fully valid. The mandate has been extended to 31 December 2022. Watch the update video from 1 April.
1. To whom does the vaccination mandate apply?
The new mandate introduced by Law Decree 172 applies to all healthcare workers. In particular, it concerns the following regulated professions:
• Pharmacist
• Medical practitioner and surgeon
• Dental practitioner
• Veterinary surgeon
• Biologist
• Physicist
• Chemist
• Psychologist
• Nurse
• Paediatric nurse
• Midwife
• Medical diagnostic radiographer
• Audiometric technician
• Biomedical laboratory technician
• Neurophysiopathology technician
• Orthopaedic technician
• Hearing aid specialist
• Cardiovascular pathophysiology and cardiovascular perfusion technician
• Dental hygienist
• Dietitian
• Podiatrist
• Physiotherapist
• Speech and language therapist
• Orthoptist – ophthalmic assistant
• Neuro and psychomotor therapist of the developmental age
• Psychiatric rehabilitation technician
• Occupational therapist
• Professional healthcare educator
• Environmental and workplace prevention technician
• Health visitor
https://www.salute.gov.it/portale/temi/p2_6.jsp?id=808&area=professioni-sanitarie&menu=vuoto&tab=2
There is, however, a small legislative lacuna, and on this point please refer to the factsheet attached here detailing the professionals to whom the vaccination mandate applies and those who are exempt.
2. What does the mandate entail?
Healthcare professionals are mandated to undergo a complete vaccination course, which now also includes the third or "booster" dose. The statutory provision refers to a vaccine for the prevention of SARS-CoV-2 infection, whereas the package leaflets of the vaccines refer instead to vaccines against the Covid-19 disease. Therefore, as things stand, the mandate refers to a medical treatment that does not exist.
3. From when does the mandate apply?
From 15 December 2021 until 15 June 2022.
4. What happens to suspensions already ordered under the old wording of Law Decree 44/2021?
Suspension measures ordered pursuant to Article 4 of Law Decree 44/2021, under its old wording, were effective only until 31/12/2021. This means that, from 01/01/2022, healthcare professionals who have not already been suspended anew under the new provisions are no longer suspended and may resume work. Self-employed professionals may simply reopen their surgeries and resume seeing patients. Employees may report for work. To do so, however, they must obtain a basic Covid-19 green certificate (Green Pass) obtained via a swab test, because the new rules on the vaccination mandate do not affect the legislation that established the workplace Green Pass mandate. Alternatively, for those who cannot or do not wish to return to work with a Green Pass, you may send the letter attached here and await the employer's response.
5. What should I do if I receive a letter extending the suspension already issued?
Suspensions ordered under the old wording of Law Decree 44/2021 have expired and are no longer valid. Should the professional regulatory body, the local health authority (ASL) or the employer send a letter extending the suspension, it would be advisable to challenge it using the model letter attached here.
6. What is the procedure for verifying compliance with the vaccination mandate set out in the new Article 4 of Law Decree 44/2021?
Law Decree 172/2021 completely redrafted Article 4 of Law Decree 44/2021, changing both the procedure and the competent authority.
The new procedure is as follows:
a) The National Federation (for example, in the case of doctors and dentists, the FNOMCeO) checks via access to the national Covid-19 green certification platform whether those registered on the rolls are vaccinated or not;
b) The Federation transmits the names of professionals who appear unvaccinated to the provincial regulatory orders;
c) The Provincial Order writes to the member, requesting them to clarify their vaccination status within five days of receiving the invitation letter.
The possible responses are:
(i) sending the vaccination certificate (hypothetically not registered on the national platform, or relating to a vaccination administered abroad),
(ii) sending a certificate:
- of recovery from Covid-19, which precludes undergoing vaccination for at least six months and up to twelve months from recovery itself,
- of deferral of the vaccination on medical grounds (e.g. ongoing clinical allergy investigations),
- of exemption from the vaccine
d) The healthcare worker responds to the provincial order detailing their situation. Compliance with the procedure by the order is of fundamental importance for the validity of any subsequent measure. In administrative proceedings, the data subject has the right to access administrative documents. Therefore, the response also includes a request for access to administrative documents. The response template is attached here.
7. How to proceed with booking the vaccine
For all those who do not hold a certificate of recovery, deferral, or exemption, it is advisable to proceed with booking the vaccination. It is advisable to make full use of the timeframe provided by the law and, therefore, book the vaccination for the twentieth day following receipt of the invitation issued by the provincial order. For instance, in the case of an invitation letter received on 30/12/2021, the vaccine should be booked for 19/01/2022. Please note that deadlines expiring on a public holiday are automatically extended to the following working day. The booking letter is attached here.
Vaccination centres no longer require bookings nowadays because footfall has fallen considerably. Nevertheless, it is still advisable to send a PEC (certified email) or registered letter to the vaccination centre specifying the date on which you will attend for the vaccine; this will be needed to provide a copy to the professional order or employer.
8. What should I do after booking the vaccine?
After booking the vaccine, a few days before the appointment, you must write to the pharmacy or vaccination centre where the booking was made using the letter attached here accompanied by the informed consent document attached here. Please note: the letter must be sent by registered post with advice of receipt (raccomandata A/R) or by certified email (PEC).
9. Do I need to attend the vaccination centre or pharmacy on the day of the appointment?
Yes, it is advisable to attend the pharmacy or vaccination centre on the day of the booking. It is not necessary to be accompanied by a lawyer. It is useful to go with a companion who can act as a witness. In any case, it is advisable to record what happens at the vaccination centre, even covertly by keeping the mobile phone recorder running in a pocket or bag.
You must take with you a copy of the letter requesting information along with the informed consent form, together with proof of dispatch by certified email (PEC) or registered post. At this point, it is advisable to ask the vaccinator whether they have the required medical prescription and whether they have the answers to the questions on the informed consent form.
They will have neither.
An important clarification that I owe to the astute observation of Avv. Roberto De Petro, whom I thank: a prescription can only be issued following a medical history examination (anamnesis); therefore, one must first ask the vaccinator to take the medical history of the patient due to receive the inoculation, and then issue the medical prescription based on the findings of that medical history. It is self-evident that anyone with a history of drug allergies, anaphylactic shock, drug intolerances or adverse drug reactions, anyone who has recently received other vaccines (for example, the tetanus vaccine), and anyone taking medication—especially corticosteroids—must bring these circumstances to the vaccinator's attention, even if they were not deemed eligible for an exemption by their general practitioner.
At this point, you must ask the pharmacy or vaccination centre to issue a written statement to the following effect:
"The undersigned declares that they are unable to issue a medical prescription for the vaccine for Mr/Ms and unable to answer the enquiries set out in the informed consent form sent via PEC.]"
If there is a refusal to sign the document, it will be captured in the recording and, in any event, noted by the witness.
In all cases, it is essential to ask for and note down the full names of the persons you speak with (vaccinating doctor, pharmacist, nurse, etc.). They cannot refuse to provide their names.
Everything you need to do and know is set out in this video.
Attend having printed and to hand:
1- The informed consent prepared by Studio Fusillo
2- The five AIFA determinations requiring a medical prescription for the vaccines (found in the final point on the last page): Pfizer - Astrazeneca - Moderna - J & J - Novavax
10. What should I do after the futile visit to the vaccination centre or pharmacy?
Three distinct outcomes are possible:
1. The vaccinating doctor does not feel able to assume responsibility for administering the vaccination and issues a certificate of deferral or exemption from vaccination. With this certificate, you obtain the Super Green Pass.
2. The vaccinating doctor issues nothing, but we have the recording and/or the police report: you must send the letter drafted by Avvocato Fusillo to your provincial regulatory order within three days.
At this stage, the decision rests with the provincial orders, which may accept the justifications provided or, as appears more likely, proceed to suspend the healthcare professional concerned anyway.
3. Should the strategy in the previous point prove ineffective and you are suspended regardless, legal proceedings may be brought to have the suspension overturned. However, the strategy described serves to secure a stronger position in the judicial review / appeal proceedings against the suspension that will follow, and to lay the groundwork for a claim for damages for all those who have been suspended.
What should I do if the vaccinating doctor, having noted my clinical conditions, prescribes further investigations or states that I must be vaccinated in a protected setting (a hospital with resuscitation/ICU facilities in case of anaphylactic shock)?
The doctor's certificate prescribing further investigations constitutes a vaccine deferral certificate. The certificate exempts the holder from the mandate to be vaccinated until those investigations are completed. Therefore, you must notify the order and book the tests for the furthest date possible.
Should there be an instruction to administer the vaccine in a protected setting, you must likewise book the vaccination at a hospital and reiterate the requests already made during the initial visit at the hospital site (see points 8 and 9).
The letter to send to the order to report the outcome of the visit in the case in question is attached here.
11. What should I do during the suspension?
Every crisis is also an opportunity. Anyone suspended from their employment may accept and perform other work for the duration of the suspension. Many professionals will be able to reopen their practices, for example as naturopaths, who are not subject to a vaccination mandate. The period of suspension can be useful for registering with a professional regulatory body in another European Union country where the vaccine is not mandatory. It is important to organise one's life so as to begin breaking dependence on the Italian Republic, which has proven so harmful in recent years.
Immediate strategy for suspended healthcare workers to turn the provisions of Law Decree 172 of 26 November to their own advantage
