Skip to content

GUIDE TO MASKS AND SWAB TESTS

By ministerial ordinance of 28 April 2023, published in the Official Gazette, General Series, No. 100 of 29 April 2023 and available HERE, Health Minister Schillaci regulated the obligations concerning the use of personal protective equipment (face masks) and undergoing PCR swab testing for the detection of the SARS-CoV-2 virus. The ordinance entered into force on 1 May and its original period of validity until 31 December 2023 was extended until 30 June 2024 by ordinance of the Ministry of Health of 27 December 2023, published in the Official Gazette, General Series, No. 302 of 29 December 2023. The ordinance has now expired and has not been renewed by the Ministry of Health. 

On 1 July 2024, the Ministry of Health issued a circular, available HERE, in which it "recommends that the Medical Directors of the aforementioned facilities, in their capacity as holders of hygiene and health functions, assess the appropriateness of ordering the use of respiratory protective devices within their own settings, taking into account the spread of airborne viruses, the characteristics of the environments, and the categories of patients, workers, or visitors who use them, based on the level of risk of infection and/or transmission (for example, in the presence of respiratory symptoms or taking seasonality into account) and the potential for developing severe disease in the event of exposure."

What legal status does a circular hold?

It is worth clarifying at the outset that circulars are not listed among the sources of law, which comprise the Constitution, primary statutes and acts having the force of law (legislative decrees and decree-laws), regulations, and customs (Article 1 of the Preliminary Provisions to the Civil Code). In addition to domestic sources of law, EU treaties and European Union regulations apply directly within national legal systems and take precedence over domestic provisions in the event of conflict. Sources of law operate within a hierarchical pyramid, meaning that a lower-ranking provision cannot conflict with a higher-ranking one.

Circulars are internal administrative acts that bind neither citizens nor judges, nor even the public administration itself, which may depart from the content of a circular if it contradicts the law. This is demonstrated by the fact that circulars cannot be challenged before administrative courts. Anyone, therefore, seeking to mandate the use of face masks by relying on the circular of 1 July 2024 would be committing an unlawful act, since the circular is not a source of rights or obligations.

Let us now examine the text of the ministerial circular, which is distinguished by its particular ambiguity.

It should be noted that medical, pharmacological, or healthcare treatments cannot be mandated except by virtue of a primary statute, as provided by Article 32 of the Constitution. Therefore, neither the Minister of Health nor any administrative authority may compel citizens to use a medical device such as a surgical mask, unless a statute expressly provides for it. Indeed, throughout the COVID-19 emergency period, a series of legislative acts were enacted precisely to mandate the use of face masks. All of these laws have expired and are no longer in force.

The circular of 1 July therefore does not state—because it cannot lawfully do so—that medical directors of hospitals, care homes (RSAs), and other healthcare facilities may mandate the use of face masks; instead, it merely advises medical directors themselves "to assess the appropriateness of ordering the use of respiratory protective devices." Under this provision of the circular, medical directors may, at most, recommend the use of masks, but they cannot impose them on anyone.

Medical recommendations are not mandatory, and everyone is free to accept them or not. This is laid down in Article 1 of Law No. 219 of 2017, which prohibits initiating or continuing any medical or diagnostic treatment without the free and informed consent of the person concerned. Compulsory medical treatments are also prohibited by Article 5 of the Oviedo Convention, ratified in Italy by Law No. 145/2001.

It must be added that many healthcare facilities, such as hospitals, are public places or places open to the public, where appearing with one's face disguised, masked, or unrecognisable is prohibited (Article 5 of the Consolidated Public Safety Act [TULPS] and Article 5 of Law No. 152/1975). A medical director cannot demand that patients, workers, and visitors to a healthcare facility commit unlawful acts.

What should you do if a healthcare facility denies access or treatment to a person because they refuse to wear a mask?

    The best approach is to follow these lines of conduct:

    1. Carry a copy of this guide with you;
    2. Request a written copy of the document mandating masks and point out that the circular does not establish any obligation and does not authorise the medical director to mandate anything;
    3. Always ask for the full names of the persons attempting to enforce mask wearing;
    4. In the case of individuals asked to wear a mask because they display symptoms of respiratory illness, ask to be examined by a doctor and to receive a certificate attesting to those symptoms;
    5. If medical care is refused because the patient is not wearing a mask, point out that a formal criminal complaint will be lodged for private violence (Article 610 of the Criminal Code) and failure to provide assistance (Article 593 of the Criminal Code);
    6. Send a formal notice of default (diffida) to the healthcare facility, the text of which can be downloaded HERE.

    Please note: these considerations apply to patients and visitors of healthcare facilities.

    What can workers do?

    The situation for workers is somewhat different, as many employers (and unfortunately many court judgments) continue to assert that mandating masks is lawful under Article 2087 of the Civil Code. This represents an erroneous interpretation of the provision and fails to respect workers' fundamental rights; however, in their case, an individual assessment of each specific circumstance is advisable, as there is a risk of disciplinary action and potentially dismissal for anyone who fails to comply with employer directives on masks.

    What about swab tests?

    Following the expiry of the ministerial ordinance on 30 June 2024, there is no longer any provision—however unlawful—that makes the provision of healthcare services conditional upon undergoing a PCR test. The considerations already set out regarding face masks apply with even greater force. No one can compel a patient to undergo testing for the detection of SARS-CoV-2, and it is entirely impermissible to refuse healthcare, diagnostic, or therapeutic services to anyone who chooses not to take the test.